“Cottage was comfy if very dated. Location is great. Nice view of the inlet from the porch.”
“Breakfast options were limited. Very cute location, right on the water. You can have your morning coffee on the hotel's porch while the waves hit the shore. Very serene!”
“Location and they upgraded us to an ocean view room without having to ask. Super clean and comfortable room.”
“The location on shelter island is picturesque and peaceful. It's a historic hotel with a strong character that feels genuine. The hotel is on a bit of a bluff so the room views (of the peconic river/bay) are great. Pool also on a nice view position... Staff is Awesome. Room is oldschool but very clean and (new)comfortable bed. -small flat screen good for first 2017 football Sunday. -good wifi -love the 1983 telephone!”
“Staff excellent, restaurant and bar excellent, location beautiful”
“The staff was excellent, but especially Zoe when we checked in - she was professional, lovely and made us feel very special (it was my birthday when we checked in!). Also, at the hotels big cookout that afternoon/evening, the bartenders treated us like royalty - especially Vladimir and JP. My husband and I would highly recommend this hotel and we expect to return next summer!”
“The staff was great. They were more than accommodating and friendly. Love that the local kids were given jobs for the summer. Loved sitting in the the sun rooms and the deck reading and relaxing. Loved the old Long Island feel ambiance. Loved the homemade granola.”
“Friendly staff, great food. The restaurant is excellent. In terms of location, it's a perfect vantage point to see the sunset while eating dinner or having cocktails.”
“Good location. Historic hotel - lots of "patina".”
“Hotel was awesome location, loved drinks on the front lawn”